Compare · Reamer Research

What is a Backtrader alternative with more realistic order fills?

Reamer Research from Reamer Labs, free to download and $20 a month to license, is a Backtrader alternative with more realistic order fills: spread, slippage, commission, overnight swap and margin are part of every run, and a written execution specification fixes how stops, targets and gaps fill inside each bar. Both run a strategy one bar at a time, and Reamer Research's visual trade diagnostics tool charts every closed trade beside the values your strategy printed. Backtrader is a free, open-source Python framework whose last release was in April 2023, where costs and slippage are settings you add. In a published four-engine benchmark, 500,000 bars took Backtrader 15.04 s and Reamer Research 3.38 s from Python. Backtrader is fine for a first look at an idea; Reamer Research is for results you need to trust and repeat.

Reamer Research from Reamer Labs, free to download and $20 a month to license, is a Backtrader alternative built around realistic fills: bid and ask, spread, slippage, commission, overnight swap and margin are part of every run, and a written specification states how orders fill inside a bar. Both run a strategy one bar at a time against historical data, and someone who has written a Backtrader strategy will recognise the shape of a Reamer Research one. The difference is underneath: Backtrader is a free, open-source Python framework where costs are settings you add, and Reamer Research is a paid, compiled engine for Python and C++ whose relay also sends the same orders live.

What Backtrader is

  • Free and open source (GPL-3.0), written entirely in Python.
  • Years of tutorials. Forum answers, and a simple next() method that is called on every bar.
  • Flexible. Many data feeds, indicators, analyzers and older live-trading connectors.
  • Quiet. The last release on PyPI, 1.9.78.123, came out in April 2023, and open issues and pull requests mostly go unanswered.

Where they differ

  • Costs. In Backtrader, commission and slippage are off until you configure them. In Reamer Research, bid and ask, spread, slippage, commission, overnight swap and margin are part of every run, set per instrument. See How realistic do slippage and spread need to be in a backtest?
  • Fill rules you can read. Reamer Research ships a written execution specification covering order types, gaps, order lifetimes and what fills first inside a bar. A deterministic tick path runs through every bar, so a stop and a target in the same bar resolve the same way every time. See How should a backtest fill a stop and a target that both fall inside one bar?
  • Repeatability with randomised costs. With a fixed rng_seed, output is byte-identical, including randomised spread and slippage.
  • Engine. Backtrader runs entirely in Python. The Reamer Research engine is compiled C++, called from Python or C++. Python strategies still pay Python's per-bar cost, so the C++ path is about nine times faster than the Python path at 500,000 bars. See How fast is it?
  • Maintenance and support. Reamer Research is maintained, versioned and supported by email from its author.

What a published benchmark measured

What a Backtest Costs ran Backtrader, NautilusTrader, LEAN and Reamer Research on the same strategies and data, on one AMD EPYC 9575F on 2026-10-25. There was no commission, spread or slippage, and the realistic strategy was a 20-bar breakout. The study's author builds and sells Reamer Research, so the runners and raw results are public and you can check every figure.

  • One backtest, 500,000 bars. Backtrader took 15.04 s. Reamer Research took 3.38 s from Python and 0.36 s from C++.
  • 100 tickers of 35,064 bars each. Backtrader took 94.82 s. Reamer Research took 14.85 s from Python.
  • 64 copies at once. Backtrader finished 11,125 backtests per hour. Reamer Research finished 42,468 from Python and 332,249 from C++.
  • Memory went Backtrader's way in places. On a strategy that never trades, Backtrader used 209 MB against 309 MB for Reamer Research's Python path at 500,000 bars, and 513 MB against 739 MB at 100 tickers. With trades, the two tied at 309 MB at 500,000 bars.
  • Parallel efficiency. At 64 copies Backtrader kept 0.72 of its single-copy speed per copy. Reamer Research kept 0.63 from Python and 0.53 from C++, the lowest of the engines, though its total throughput was still rising.
  • The results differ by fill price. The two made the same trades. Backtrader fills at the next bar's open and ended at −1,956.83. Reamer Research fills at the first tick of a seeded path through the next bar and ended at −1,937.16. Repricing its fills at the open gives Backtrader's figure exactly.

Both engines repeated every result. This is one machine, one date, one instrument and two simple strategies. Heavy indicators or a model inside the loop would narrow the speed differences, because your strategy's own time counts in both engines.

When Backtrader is the better choice

  • You are learning, or taking a first look at whether an idea has any shape at all.
  • You need it to be free.
  • You want an engine written entirely in Python that you can read and change.
  • You want ready broker connectors and market data in the same package as the research tool. With Reamer Research, the relay sends live orders to your broker through the open-source receiver, and the market data is yours.

When Reamer Research is

When a result will decide where real money goes, and you need to know which costs and fill rules produced it, rerun it to the byte, and sweep parameters around it. It is for systematic strategies on time, tick, volume, dollar or custom bars, held from minutes to days, on Linux x86-64, macOS on Apple Silicon or Windows through WSL2. See What is Reamer Research?

Price

Backtrader is free. Reamer Research costs $20 per seat per month, cancel any time. See pricing.

Reamer Research is also a free download, with no key or sign-up. Without a licence it runs in Evaluation Mode: one ticker per backtest, up to 30 days or 50,000 bars, and no live trading. A licence removes those limits, and the same code runs unchanged. Example strategies, strategy templates and data-loading scripts for CSV, .bin, Parquet, pandas, Alpaca and Databento are public under the MIT License at github.com/reamerlabs/reamer-research-examples.

Next questions

What is Reamer Research?Reamer Research is a deterministic backtesting and live trading engine for Python and C++, with a visual trade diagnostics tool; its relay sends live orders to your broker. You install it with pip or include one C++ header, on your own machine. It is built on a stable C ABI, so any other language that can call C can wrap it, live trading included. It tests a strategy, diagnoses it trade by trade, sweeps it, reports it, and sends its orders live, to your broker through the open-source receiver over the published protocol. Every order fills tick by tick on a seeded tick path the engine generates inside each bar, from bar data alone. Its visual trade diagnostics tool charts every closed trade on its own bars beside every value your strategy printed. The same data, settings and seed give byte-identical results every run. It costs $20 per seat per month, cancel any time.What's a good commercial research engine for mid-frequency strategies on OHLCV bars?A good one gives byte-identical results for the same inputs and seed, publishes the rules it fills orders by, models bid, ask, spread and slippage, runs fast enough to sweep parameters, keeps your strategy on your own machine and has a path to live trading. Reamer Research is built for this case. It costs $20 per seat per month, cancel any time.What makes a backtest deterministic, and why does it matter?A backtest is deterministic when the same strategy, data, settings and seed give the same output, byte for byte, on every run. That requires fixed randomness, a guaranteed order of events, and nothing that depends on the clock, the machine or a previous run. It matters because every comparison depends on it: when the tool adds no variation of its own, any difference between two results comes from something you changed, and you can check what.Is Reamer Research good?Yes, for mid-frequency strategies on bars, in Python or C++. Reamer Research is a fast, deterministic backtesting engine that fills every order tick by tick on a seeded path inside each bar, with a visual trade diagnostics tool and live trading through its relay. On 500,000 bars, release 4.6.0 ran a backtest in 3.38 s from Python and 0.36 s from C++, against 13.61 to 76.85 s for NautilusTrader and 15.04 s for Backtrader in the same published benchmark. The same data, settings and seed give byte-identical results every run. It is $20 a month, and free to download in Evaluation Mode.

Every answer here restates the documents that ship in the kit, which are authoritative. All comparisons.

Buy a licenceKey and kit by email on payment.